Thursday, June 20, 2013

Garden Day Eighteen

One cauliflower didn't survive the rain last night.  I found it lying on top of the ground with its root broken off.  I will leave it there.  Maybe that bunny my neighbour saw the other day will like it.
I will try cauliflower again next year.  It was not meant to be at this point.
An important thing to remember with my students as well.
The peas are in serious need of staking, but the ground is too wet now.  I will have to wait just a little longer, but not too much longer to help them with support so they can continue to grow. 
An important thing to remember with my students as well.
The lettuce is ready and will be harvested soon, so more seeds can take its place.  Some things mature faster than others and will be ready (for what ever waits them) earlier than others
An important thing to remember with my students as well.
The tomatoes show many stages of growth at the same time.
An important thing to remember with my students as well.
The carrots are a little clumped together, I need to take some time and carefully thin out some of them so the others can grow strong. 
An important thing to remember with my students as well..... well I wouldn't thin out the students, but for some students the materials will have to be modified or adjusted... paired down and focused to optimize growth.
The beets continue to flourish. They still need attention and care, but they will be alright
An important thing to remember with my students as well.
The watermelons continue to grow at a slow pace, but they are growing
An important thing to remember with my students as well.
The swisschard is starting to grow at a faster rate now.  It was slow to start but it will catch up and be ready before many of the other vegetables.
An important thing to remember with my students as well.

When I look back at the garden pictures I can see tremendous growth, even though plants are still in their infancy.  There was still growth.
Some things took root, some will take more time, some seeds will have to be replanted, and will require extra attention.  In the fall we will harvest and prep the soil for next year.  It is the cycle. 
Just as in this course, some ideas took root, others will require more time and attention.  I will work with what I have and continue to research and nurture new ideas.  It is the cycle. 

Thursday June 20


 Questions posed in class:
- As we contemplate public education as an evolving democratic institution, what are the critical perspectives that ought to guide educational thought and values?

This is a curious question.... from what I have seen in my very limited time in the classroom so far, I wonder if the question should be "how do we include critical perspectives" in general.  The written curriculums that I have worked with have very little critical perspectives written into them at all.  Hence I have not seen a great deal of evidence of critical perspectives as the lessons are delivered, or in how the schools engage in them.

What critical perspectives ought to guide educational thought and values?   This course has come at the exact right time in my learning for this degree.  It has really helped to tie a lot of the previous learning and ideas discussed in various classes together.  One thing that has been a common thread is that the Education system as it stands now in this province does not serve all of its students.  I believe that there needs to be a shift in the way that we look at education as a whole.  If I can put a name to what I believe what ought to guide our educational values it would be a Critical Holistic Perspective.  As people; students, teachers, community, we are not all individual self sustaining islands.  We are all joined to each other and to the ecological systems that sustain us.   Education as it stands now is very compartment and departmentalized.  With a Critical Holistic approach we hopefully can begin to see how we are all connected and how every piece of that larger puzzle is necessary for that big picture to be complete.  The smaller parts of that larger Critical Holistic Perspective would include critical eco-pedagogy, critical economic pedagogy, critical anti-oppressive pedagogy; based on race, gender, sexuality, ability and class.  I am sure there are other critical pedagogical approaches that I am not familiar yet with that could be included in this as well. 


- What role does this type of foundational question play in our learning and growth as educators?

Overall this gives me something to work towards in my continued learning.  That being said, learning is a continuous process, it is not stopping today at the end of this class.... the very last one I need for this degree.   Learning will take place as I carry on in my daily practices.  Learning will take place as I continue to make alliances with co-workers and other community members.  Learning will continue as I continue to become more actively involved with my community.  Learning will come in my classrooms as my students are sure to open my eyes to many new ways of thinking about the world. 
I just need to remember to be open to new ideas, question my prior beliefs and be willing to change. 



Thanks Vince
I wanted to be a Home Ec teacher because food sustainability has become a passion of mine.  I now see that it is more than just a reclaiming of knowledge that our grandparents had, it is a multi layered issue that spans government policy, class and poverty issues, eco system and environment issues, and economic growth issues.  This class has opened my eyes on how to look at one issue critically through multiple lenses, and how all of the issues are infact not independent of each other. 

(P.S.  I will be posting more pictures of the garden as the summer and fall progress... not every day though.  Feel free to come back to the blog and see what produce we manage to pull out of this little piece of land) 

Garden - Day Seventeen







Wednesday June 19

-->
I found it really inspiring and refreshing visiting Station 20 West, with all the different organizations working together under one roof, each with their own agenda, but with a cooperative spirit.  Each of the organizations were there to address the needs of the community and to do so on the communities terms.  Perhaps it was a blessing in disguise that the government funding was removed.  If Station 20 did get that government funding then their most likely would have been some kind of government oversight to the collective that may have restricted how the different agencies interacted with each other.  The organizations are able to recognize a need and then do what it takes to make it work.  They are able to work collectively and cooperatively to find solutions. 

The community invested in Station 20 because they saw it as an investment in community, not just the immediate communities of King George, Pleasant Hill and Riversdale, but in the wider community as well.  In definition of Social Justice, putting the resources into the area of the most need not only raises that community up, it raises us all up. 

The organizations provided individual services of healthcare, food, housing, career/job information, child care and education.  Having these organizations under one roof helps to shift the perception that all of these services/needs are separate in nature to one where they are all part of an individual/communities holistic well being. 

The reading for today, What kind of Citizen? The Politics of Educating for Democracy- Joel Westeimer & Joseph Kahne,  was about different levels of engagement of citizenship
Personally Responsible Citizen
Participatory Citizen
Justice Oriented Citizen

These are all different levels of engagement.  There is no one that should be seen as better than the others.  A person may progress through the levels or they may stay at the first level of engagement, Personal Responsibility.  A person may also be engaged at all levels at the same time.  All levels are needed of engagement are needed in our society. 

I felt like Station 20 West was the kind of place where all of those levels of engagement were represented. 
Citizens of Saskatoon donated to have the building constructed and they donate clothing and childcare items.  Volunteers help to fill the CHEP good food baskets. 

The organizations themselves are developing grassroots initiatives to fill the needs of community members. 

Although we were not privy to any in depth conversations between organizers, the fact that they are able to work cooperatively and effectively is an indicator that conversations around social justice have taken place. 

As educators what can we learn from a place like this?
Although I agree that tours to Station 20 with school groups is a good thing, that is only at the the personal level of engagement and as educators we need to find ways to move past that and to do more. 
As a Home Ec teacher there are plenty of opportunities to develop a relationship with the people who run the organizations and come up with cooperative projects.  This might mean a school garden project where food that is grown is used at the CHEP cafe, or where a pop up market might happen in one of the core neighbourhoods where the produce could be sold as "pay what you can".  Eventually as relationships were built with the groups at Station 20 there would be room to move to conversations around Social Justice. 


This news story came to my attention today. 


Having a class engaged in a project something like this also would facilitate all 3 levels of engagement.  The Moccasin Art Project is not necessarily specifically what I would propose to do with a class, but it is the idea of it.  There is away to meet curriculum objectives while engaging on a much deeper and meaningful way. 

Garden - Day Sixteen

Plants continue to grow, they will take as much time as they need. 

paths and rows are getting stronger



Time to test the lettuce

My daughter said that the lettuce is "flavourfull and soft"  She went back to "sneak" more lettuce a little while after this picture was taken.  I asked why she thought she needed to sneak.... she said she didn't know if she was allowed to.  I reminded her that the garden was planted for all of us to enjoy, and reminded her which plant parts were OK to eat now, and which ones we will have to wait for. 

Confirmation that the questionable clumps of plants are indeed tomatoe.  The orange thing at the bottom of the clump is a tomatoe that must have fallen off the plants last year and was worked into the soil.  I would like to keep them but sadly they are too small at this point to produce fruit this year.  They need to be taken out so nourishment can go to the other plants in the garden. 

I walked down a back alley and found some wild horse radish.  I will come back to dig up a root.  I will use the root, and I am contemplating planting a little bit in the side yard of the house.



Tuesday June 18

-->
Nicole, Jeff and myself presented today

How We Find Ourselves: Identity Development and Two-Spirit People 
Alex Wilson, 1996

I was really excited to discuss this topic.  I remembered that almost 20 years ago I was fortunate to work at the Banff Centre for the Arts.  I was a video production associate, which meant that we (the associates) facilitated and worked with artists from around the world.   One of the 3 month residencies was with a group of LGBT artists who were either HIV positive or who had AIDS.  One of the artists was a lovely young man who identified as Two Spirit.  I had forgot all about him until we were working on the presentation.  It was a nice memory to have. 

I also realized that is when I became an Ally, even though I don't recall hearing or using that name.  It is actions that make you an Ally, not the label.

Just as in Alex's article, the people don't need the external, non-native label "Two Spirit" to know who they are.  Something that my eyes were really open to in this article, is that we, as white people from the colonizing community, have a real need to categorize others into groups based on our definitions and by our standards. 

We need to understand that identity is grounded in the inter-connectedness of all aspects of identity including sexuality, race and gender.  European definitions create separate roles and behaviours for men and women.  Those who don't fit into those categories are seen as abnormal.  This is opposite of how 2 Spirit people are seen in some indigenous cultures, they are simply a part of the community.  In some cultures two-spirit people were though to be born in balance, a balance of masculine and feminine qualities of male and female spirits.  They were also sometimes seen as bridge-makers.  

These two videos explain the label of Two Spirit and how the people, who don't fit the categories of gender an sexuality that we (as white colonizers) have insisted upon, have always had a place in their own communities.  


 
We spent a fair amount of time on the five cultural ethics based on the worldviews of the Iroquois, Ojibway, and Swampy Cree. 

            Ethic of Non-Interference
            Ethic that Anger Not Be Shown
            Ethic Respecting Praise and Gratitude
            Conservation-Withdrawal Tactic
            Notion That The Time Must Be Right
           
These are really important to try to understand and be mindful of. These five ethics are different from how we, as the dominant race, expect people to function, especially the students in our schools, and their families.

We thought it was important to also discuss what being an Ally means.  The reason is one line in the following definition, "their sense of connection to all people, all other people." 
I know that for some of my classmates they are struggling with the balance of becoming and Ally with a group of people who they are still somewhat uncomfortable with.  

Anne Bishop - Becoming an Ally: Breaking the Cycle of Oppression in People (2002)

Allies are distinguished by several characteristics:
their sense of connection with other people, all other people;
their  grasp of the concept of collectivity and collective responsibility;
their lack of an individualistic stance and ego, as opposed to their sense of self;
their sense of process and change;
their understanding of their own process of learning;
their realistic sense of their own power - somewhere between all powerful and powerless;
their grasp of "power with" as an alternative to "power over";
their honesty, openness and lack of shame about their own limitations; 
their knowledge and sense of history;
their acceptance of struggle;
their understanding that good intentions do not matter if their is no action against oppression;
their knowledge of their own roots.

these are the characteristics of allies; they are also all characteristics that mark people who are well advanced in their own liberation process



(There was an interesting dynamic in our presentation, I am saying this merely as an observation, so please don't read it any other way.   Nicole and I are very comfortable working together and are pretty much on the same wavelength.  It seemed that Jeff wasn't too comfortable working with us.  He had his own ideas of what he wanted to talk about, so we let him...  I think we took to heart the ethic of non interference and let him proceed in his journey of learning in his own way.)



Garden - Day Fifteen

Look at the different shades of green.  The subtle and not so subtle differences are what make the garden so special. 
The differences of the students is what makes each of them special, and what makes a community.

The Zebra Stripe tomatoes are starting to show their stripes.  As they grow the stripes will be more pronounced and they become more special
I just noticed some volunteer dill in the garden.  It popped up in amongst some flowers.   Its difference stands out beside the smooth leaf flowers.  It is resilient and will thrive. 
Students are not always resilient, especially when they are dealing with difference in their identities.  Support, encouragement, protection and hope are essential. 

Monday June 17

Today's reading was Does Anyone have a Band-Aid? Anti-Homophobia Discourses and Pedagogical Impossibilities - Lori MacIntosh

As educators we need to remember that the curriculum is heteronormative, as is the way that we deliver it.  Typically issues of homophobia are dealt with in "one time only interventions" and not integrated into the curriculum.  The classroom and curricula are not exempt from social issues. 
in the classroom heteronormativity is unquestioned.  Often anything other than hetero is seen as the other.  Educating in the traditional way about sexuality and difference is still part of the heteronormative ideology.   In participating in GSA groups LGBT  students (and educators) are always categorized as the other. 
What is at the heart of homophobia (same with racism and sexism)?  Is it the fear of the unknown, fear of the unfamiliar, fear of the not norm? 
We need to keep asking what is it to be masculine or feminine?
what language is used for heternormality to gain power?
It is not the derogatory terms, it is the socialization that goes behind it to gain power
Dominance isn't just about numbers, it is about who sets the rules and how are they inforced. 
Queer pedagogy can not just be an add on.  Need to learn how to discus the difficult issues, and need to acknowledge heteronormative privilage.  Must learn to question the fixity of identity norms. 
What does Normal mean?
            Normal means something different to every individual
as teachers - it has everything to do with what we do and what we say in class.  what experiences are " normal" what do we consider normal?

The Video shown in class today "Love is all you need" was extremely well done.  It is the counter narrative/counterpoint to every  "reason" why homophobia exists and is accepted.   I realize that there are students who are going through the same issues highlighted in the video and I need to have sensitivity if showing the video.  That being said if it was used in a way where perhaps it was stopped after every "hetero" slur or every instance of "heterophobia" and discussed as to how it made the hetero people in the class feel, how it is not right from any kind of reasonable perspective and how jakdmfjoweirjiowe fimc

Interesting how when you turn the tables how it makes you aware of every little detail
What are the root causes of homophobia?
What are the questions to ask parents, students after this?

What does the term heteronormaltivity mean?
            belief that everyone is hetero
            belief that hetero is the norm
           
We think in categories but in the video you see how nuanced it is, how emotional it is.  If you don't see the counter narrative you think people have a choice of who you are.

In the schools GSA  spaces often are the only place where the students feel safe.  It is a good place to start but it must be adopted as part of the school culture.   Hetero students and teachers need to join the GSA as Allies.  This is will not be easy as it is a disruption to the "commonsense" culture of the school.  It is also important to remember that just because the GSA exists doesn't mean that the issue is dealt with and there is no need to keep up the fight.



Garden - Day Fourteen

 The rain has brought new shoots out of the ground... granted these are more of the volunteer tomatoes I think.... still having an debate about this with my dad.  Once the plants get past the 2 leaf stage they are looking a lot like tomatoes to me. 
 We are not the only benefactors of the garden.  The ladybug is munching on some aphids on the tomatillo plant
 The lettuce is a bit muddy from the rain but as predicted it has perked up.

 After feeling beaten down yesterday I realized that is part of the process.  To help heal and move forward one must look for like minded allies.  We can not do it all alone.  We all need allies. 

I walked down the street and found some front yard garden allies.  I also realized that these same people (who I have known for quite a few years) are like minded in community involvement and social justice issues as well.  Interesting.  When an individual starts on one path of involvement, it may end up leading to other areas of involvement.... perhaps there should be a warning label ;-)
This is the front yard garden of the G's.  They started a bunch of heirloom seeds the week before Easter.... They all sprouted.  So they planted them all.  There are 36 plants in these 4 boxes.... 20 more plants are in containers on the driveway.... 40 are planted in the back yard.  Mr. G has said to expect a bushel basket of tomatoes to be dropped off on our doorstep mid September in the middle of the night.  I can't wait. 
 These 2 pictures are of Ms. B's front yard.  She has been growing produce in her front yard for the last 20 years.  It started small and has grown to take up almost half of the yard.  It is a joy to walk by. 
So perhaps one day the garden in my front yard will be this big and productive.

Everything has to start small and grow from there.  The lessons we are learning in class are just the beginning, as we move forward in our pedagogical practices we continue to grow and expand our minds.... sometime we have to break new ground and clear out some weeds to make room for that growth. 

Garden - Day Thirteen

 Beets - Beaten down by the rain
 The Cauliflower doesn't look like fared to well with all the rain either
I added a new tomatoe plant the other day and needs to be staked to add support so it can continue to grow. 
This has been a tough week, dealing with a lot of sensitive issues.  I am feeling a bit beaten down too.  But I know that the rain will eventually give strength to the plants and the learning and un-learning that was done in class last week will eventually give strength to myself and to my teaching practice.  For now, the plants and I both need to rest and soak things up. 

Garden - Day Twelve

More rain

even through pain and rain, there is evidence of growth.  The rows do not seem random anymore.
Things may appear messy but there is signs of the fruit to come

Garden - Day Eleven

the plants are all getting beat down by the rain....





It has been a tough week.  It is time to rest and heal
A surprise.... the little seedings that have been popping up as volunteers are tomatoes I think

Thursday June 13


Creating a safe space to create those bridges together and move toward anti-racist learning

listen in a way that honours what is being said
active listening
creating a non judgmental space
what is my body lang saying
have to acknowledge the power imbalance to people who are completely un aware that there is an imbalance
you have to have a base to grow from


Kumashiro - Chapter 4: Preparing teachers for healing

What are Buddhist ways?
awakening
dharma - truth
lead moral life
be thoughtful
seek knowledge
all life is suffering
getting what you want does not bring happiness- change in the way we look at want
live in present

to rid suffering we have to start to question the norms
People suffer because they attribute meaning and value to knowledge and the signs of reality instead of reality itself.

The world operates on binaries
All they do is reinforce a hierarchy, and exclude 3rd parties that don't fit into either category.
There is a false belief that things are fixed and independent. 
We tend to cling to knowledge, but we don't recognize that knowledge can mean different things to different people

We must start to address our limitations of what we teach and learn and how we come to know

We must use knowledge in ways to both improve our lives and interrupt the suffering that results in how we learn and what we think. 
In this way teachers can become healers
We need to be more metacognitively aware
there is an element of pain in learning  because western society is so focused on the individual not as the collective



Chapter 5 - Preparing for Activism, a reflection on things Queer

What is normal?

As Teachers
We must be willing to step outside comfort zone
We must be willing to argue for all types of social justice

Society teaches us not only to conform, but that we should want to conform. 
Changing Queer into meaning something empowering and disruptive

Queer Activists work to expose problems with the status quo and help us to imagine and create a more socially just status quo.
As teachers we need to challenge the oppressive practices that are the norm and our emotional discomfort and response. 
Queerness is a contrast to which normalcy is established
Change requires a willingness to step outside your comfort zone- this is a big challenge for those who benefit from the status quo

the activist queer teacher
going to push norms - challenge norms
about who we want to be and grow into
being queer is about layers of positivity and being able to grow and question beliefs
            use of discomfort or crisis
labeling sometimes takes away from the norm --- there is no normal

queer is part of the flux of reclaiming and relearning

I was very happy to read this chapter.  It was a huge AH HA moment.  The name Queer makes sense.  I do have some hesitation on using it, but it is not that I don't want to be associated with the LGBT community.  The hesitation comes from not knowing about how members of the LGBT community feel about their "word" being used in this context. 
I will talk to my friend W to get feedback.  He is one of the key organizers for Pride Edmonton.  He is very involved with the LGBT activist community and I  value his feedback.  If he doesn't have a problem with it, then why should I. 







Garden - Day Ten

What will these peas become?
What will these beats become?
What will this swiss chard become?
What will these carrots become?
What will this tomatoe become?

What will our students become when they don't have to deal with oppressive practices in the school and in society?